SAFETY

Can a pilot be too educated?



The recent mishaps (a Bombardier CRJ200 double flame-out, the transatlantic British Airways three-engined Boeing 747 flight, China Eastern Airlines Airbus A340 tailscrape, for example), lead me to wonder if safety is a top priority for airlines..

These events belong to the human factors field. The issue is not the error(s) made by the crews, but their behaviours.

It is interesting to link this to the following situation. As a former university assistant professor in psychology, I lectured and researched human factors and aviation safety. I then joined the aviation industry as an airline pilot. Both experiences gave me a rare profile. Since my last company went bankrupt in 2002, I have not been able to find job as a pilot. The most frequently given reason? I am too educated.

While airlines only base hiring on flying hours, they forget that all accidents/incidents involve highly experienced pilots.

Safety departments are not innovative enough about training, which must educate and convince to influence operator attitude.

The mishaps reveal a failure regarding the complete training chain: technical, crew resource management, and so on, but this failure is much deeper considering attitudes weren’t swayed. Moreover, attitudes are built mainly from training, not from experience.

Frank Caron
Pellouailles, France

Printed in the Flight International letters section, 7-13 June 2005
CLOSE WINDOW